Week 11 NFL Picks: Put on Your Tin Foil Hat

Microsoft Outlook goes down! Air traffic control goes down! Chase Bank goes down! The power grid is going down! Jensen Huang sold state secrets to his Chinese spy paramour! Cyber attacks or AI takeover? Who’s to say? Also, the NFL is rigged and that’s why my record is so bad! (Just kidding on that last one). With all the craziness in the news this week, it’s time to get out our tin foil hats and let our conspiracy theories get out of hand.

Photo Courtesy of Abbie Parr/Associated Press

Tier 1: Lee Harvey Oswald Didn’t Kill JFK (Season Record: 6-13-1)

Raiders +9.5 over Broncos

49ers -3 over Vikings

This “theory” is increasingly coming close to just being accepted as true. The evidence doesn’t really add up to say Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone, and likely wasn’t even the only shooter. Did he fire the fatal shot? Maybe. But he almost certainly had help, and there were plenty of powerful people and organizations who had a vested interest in getting rid of Kennedy. My one question here is how long until “Jeffrey Epstein didn’t kill himself” surpasses “Lee Harvey Oswald was the lone gunman” as the most conventionally accepted American conspiracy? 10 years? 20 years? Are we already there?

Fernando Mendoza couldn’t have been handed a tougher two-game stretch for the first starts of his NFL career, and while baptisms by fire rarely go well for rookie quarterbacks maybe doing it ten weeks into the season is better than doing it opening week. Mendoza got to experience life against a topflight NFL defense last week and he’ll get another one in Denver this week. Do I expect him to win this game? I do not. Do I trust Bo Nix to blow anyone out? I also do not. I think if Mendoza can protect the football and avoid giving Denver’s defense any scores or Denver’s offense multiple short-field opportunities, then the Raiders can at least hang around in this game.

My love for Brian Flores as a defensive coordinator is well-chronicled, but Brock Purdy is having a career year. Kirk Cousins looked reasonably comfortable assimilating back into Kevin O’Connell’s offense last week, but I’m still holding some reservations about Minnesota’s offense. I like the 49ers to win, and I’m going to bet another Minnesota under (46.5 total points) this week. Plus, it’s a primetime game, which means we definitely won’t get the best out of Kirko Chainz.

Photo Courtesy of Popular Science

Tier 2: The 1969 Moon Landing Was Staged (Season Record: 10-13)

Bucs +7 over Lions

Jaguars -5.5 over Giants

One small step for man…because it happened in a Hollywood basement? And Cobain, can you hear the spheres singing songs off Station to Station? That’s how the theory goes anyway. Personally, it kind of seems like having an operation professional enough in 1969 to pull this off and keep it from definitively breaking for 57 years might just be harder than actually going to the moon.

After rough starts to the season, both Tampa Bay and Detroit seem to be rounding into form as we hit the home stretch. Detroit is getting healthier in the secondary, although that’s been countered by injuries to the front seven, including the horrifying Jack Campbell neck injury and Aidan Hutchinson Bill Gramaticaing himself in Munich last week. Speaking of, I know Detroit is at home but they are returning from Munich while Tampa Bay is coming off a bye. Considering all of that, this line feels a minimum of half-a-point too high.

Jacksonville has pushed all of their chips into the middle and our showing no signs of letting their foot off the gas. Trades for Jessie Bates and Jordan Davis tell everyone that they think they can win a Super Bowl this year. I’m not sure they are right, but I’m also not positive I’m wrong. One thing I do know is that they have been content to just pound every bad team they’ve played. I’d put the Giants in that category and be willing to bet that they do the same.

Melissa Tamez/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

Tier 3: The Frozen Envelope Theory (Season Record: 20-14)

Bears -11.5 over Saints

Panthers -2.5 over Ravens

Commanders +6.5 over Bengals

I had to work a few sports conspiracy theories into a sports column. The Frozen Envelope Theory suggests that the NBA rigged the 1985 NBA drift by freezing the New York Knicks envelope so that David Stern could award them the first overall pick, which would become Patrick Ewing. Do I believe this actually happened? Like 36% yes.  Did it ultimately matter considering that it took the Knicks over 40 years from that moment to win an NBA title? It did not.

I told you I’ve sworn off the Saints. Even a monster line can’t keep me away. After a week off, I think Caleb Williams has been stewing on his four-interception-game from two weeks ago. He and Ben Johnson very openly want a prolific and heralded offense. Don’t expect them to take their foot off the gas even if things get out of hand.

Carolina is better than Lamar-less Baltimore. Derrick Henry is finally showing signs of wear after years of looking impervious to time and mileage. I’m not sure he’s the guy who can punish a bad run defense as consistently as he used to. I do worry a little bit about the Toby Keith corollary for this, but I think it would be a little foolish to bet on that premise.

Cincinnati looked like one of the best teams in the league Monday night. Joe Burrow was on, yet again, from the opening kickoff. When he and Chase and Higgins are cooking, they are capable of beating anybody. This defense is also capable of the kind of stinkers making them vulnerable to losing to anybody too though. I don’t trust them with a spread this big. Not when they are at the peak of their market value, coming off a short week and Washington is coming in off a relatively long week. Jayden Daniels is playing good football. The Commanders defense has been one of the more surprisingly competent units in the NFL. Dan Quinn is still a walking game management disaster, but this spread is big enough that he could brain fart the game away at the end and Washington still cover.

Tier 4: The Phantom Punch (Season Record: 17-18)

Bills -16.5 over Dolphins

Chiefs -15.5 over Cardinals

Steelers -4.5 over Eagles

The second Muhammad Ali-Sonny Liston heavyweight title match produced one of the most iconic photos of all time. It also may have been staged. The theory is that Sonny took a dive, either to pay off debts of his own or because it would have been more financially beneficial for him to lose and set up a rematch. The latter mini-theory is lent credence by the secret “rematch” clause in the fight contract.

These lines are all a little larger than I’d like, but Vegas is really going to have to goad me to lose any more money on the Dolphins, Cardinals or Eagles this year. Buffalo’s defense is sure to make the potential backdoor cover cause for shoveling down antacids in that game. Kansas City always has the propensity to fall back into “pull out just enough to win” mode, but they haven’t really been that team this year. I’m going to bank on them continuing not to be. The last is the most reasonable. Even off a short week, I think Jaylen Warren keeps Pittsburgh ahead of the chains and the Steelers pass rush makes life difficult enough on Joe Milton. I think Pittsburgh wins by a touchdown, and Jaylen Warren scores a pair of touchdowns.

USA TODAY via Reuters Connect

Tier 5: Vaccines Cause Autism (Season Record: 15-21-1)

Colts +12.5 over Texans

Titans +7.5 over Cowboys

Jets +3 over Chargers

As a pediatrician, I feel the need to lay out the truth about this one. Mr. (because he literally lost his license) Andrew Wakefield published a paper in 1998 that seemingly found a link between autism and the MMR (Measles, Mumps and Rubella) vaccine. The only problem? The paper was completely fraudulent. He intentionally targeted developmentally delayed and autistic children for one arm of the study and children not afflicted with such conditions for the other. That’s pretty much the dictionary definition of research fraud. All evidence suggests he may believe that vaccines are some “Big Pharma” scam. Big Pharma has a lot of issues…but the MMR vaccine isn’t one of them. Mr. Wakefield isn’t your champion. He’s a reprehensible human being.

Unlike Mr. Wakefield, the six teams in this tier aren’t frauds. They just suck. I don’t really want to bet on any of them, and almost assuredly will not. If forced to choose a side however, I’d just take the points and move on.

Last Week: 8-6

Season Record: 68-79-2

Cover Photo Courtesy of Stephen Swofford/Denver Gazette

Leave a Reply